Notes from a Spinning Planet: Ireland by Melody Carlson

22 Apr

Title: Notes from a Spinning Planet: Ireland

Author: Melody Carlson

Publisher: WaterBrook Press 2006

Genre: Fiction

Pages: 256

Rating:  DNF

I ran into a huge setback today in Notes from a Spinning Planet: Ireland.  I picked this and the two sequels (Mexico and Papua New Guinea) thinking they would be an interesting “See the world” type of book.  I found many problems with the book and quit 60 pages in.

  1. The book is written in a first person journaling style.  It got a bit annoying when it switched from a journal style to an almost 3rd person retelling, but happening currently events.  Does that make sense?  Every time it changed, I had to rethink how to read the book.
  2. The main character was annoying.  Maddie has been asked by her Aunt Sid to travel to Ireland for a research project.  She tells us right off that she’s never been “off the farm” (literally in her case).  Okay, I get it, she’s new to this whole traveling thing, but the culture mistakes and intolerance annoyed the crap out of me.  Don’t go to another country unless you really want to learn about and experience the culture.  In fact, before you go, read some guide books, prepare yourself to their way of life.  If you don’t, you’re not appreciating the peoples.  End of rant.
  3. The Christian angle was baffling.  Is this a book about Maddie refinding Christ?  Is this a book about her witnessing to others?  I couldn’t tell.  Maybe this was cleared up later, but I had absolutely no clue in the first fourth of the book.
  4. Beer.  The entire third and fourth chapters Maddie’s fixates on the fact that Ryan, Aunt Sid’s godson, is having a pint.  She even makes nasty comments to him about it and then mentions to him that she thinks that all Christians should not drink.  I know some Christians do not drink, but her reasoning was that “Jesus didn’t drink.”  Ryan mentions the fact that Jesus and his disciples drank wine, to which she replies “I heard it was more like grape juice.”  Her ignorance and naiveté really got me.  How did this girl live at all before now?  Fine it’s her issue, but do I have to read about her whiny thoughts about beer throughout two chapters?
  5. My last problem has to do with the targeted audience.  What age group was the book written for?  The library shelved it in Reader’s Services (adult fiction), yet it read like a teen novel.  Looking at the back of the book, the book is listed as “Fiction/Young Adult.”  Well that explains it.  The book should be shelved in the Young Adult section.
Maybe this book would appeal to me if I was 13.  As I am 29, I felt very over this type of coming of age story.  Maddie was too naive and intolerant for my tastes.  Therefore, I put it down after 60 pages.  I’m going to try another book by Melody Carlson, one that was written for adult audiences (I double checked it!).


Posted by on April 22, 2011 in Book Reviews



2 responses to “Notes from a Spinning Planet: Ireland by Melody Carlson

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: